OCS Polity Module 1 of 23: Making of the Constitution
Module 1 · Polity · about 6 hours, in five sittings

How India wrote itself a constitution

In 1765 a trading company became the government of Bengal. In 1950 the people of India gave themselves the longest written constitution in the world. This module is the 185 years in between: every Act, every crisis that forced it, and the three years in which 299 people turned all of it into one document.

Syllabus: Mains GS-II "historical underpinnings, evolution" · Prelims "Constitution"15 Acts · 1 Assembly · 1 Constitution

Before you start

Read it in five sittings: Company rule, Crown rule, the reforms of 1919 and 1935, the road to 1947, and the Assembly. Each sitting ends with a box called Pause and recall. Answer it from memory before you open the answers. That single habit is worth more than reading the module twice.

Select any sentence to highlight it or attach your own note. Everything you mark is saved and listed under My notes at the top of the page.

The engineering lens for this module

Think of the years 1773 to 1950 as a long refactoring project. A trading company's operating system was patched, release by release, until it became a government. Then Indians rewrote it from a specification of their own.

Every Act below is a release. For each one, ask three questions: what broke (the crisis that forced it), what changed (the one big change), and what it led to (the next release).

Two threads run through every release
  1. Who holds power. It moves from the Company, to the British Crown, and finally to Indians. Watch the meter on the right fill as Indians move from "none" to "all".
  2. Centre or provinces. Until 1833 power is pulled into one centre in Calcutta. From 1861 it is slowly pushed back out to the provinces. Watch the dial swing.

If you can say, for any year, where those two threads stood, you can rebuild almost every fact in this module.

1765 – 1858 · Sitting 1, about 60 minutes

The Company years

A trading firm finds itself ruling millions of people, and the British Parliament spends 85 years taking control of it.

Allahabad, 12 August 1765

The Mughal emperor Shah Alam II, defeated at Buxar the year before, sits on a makeshift throne. Robert Clive of the East India Company accepts from him the Diwani: the right to collect the revenue of Bengal, Bihar and Orissa.

A company of merchants, answerable to shareholders in London, is now the government of tens of millions of people. Nobody in London has decided who controls it.

What broke

Within a few years the arrangement was failing on every front. Company servants were growing rich on private trade and gifts. The Bengal famine of 1770 killed, by most estimates, about one in three people in Bengal while revenue collection went on. And the Company itself was close to bankrupt: in 1772 it had to ask the British government for a loan.

A company that needed the state's money while running a state was something Parliament could no longer ignore. Every Act from 1773 to 1853 is Parliament doing the same thing: regulating the Company, one step further each time.

Painted portrait of Warren Hastings in eighteenth-century dress
Warren Hastings, painted by Tilly Kettle: the first Governor-General of Bengal under the Regulating Act. He was later impeached by the British Parliament for his conduct in India, and acquitted after a trial that lasted seven years.Tilly Kettle · Public domain · source
v1773Regulating Act The first time the British government regulated the Company

One big change: Parliament steps in, and Bengal becomes the centre.

What broke
Corruption, the 1770 famine, a near-bankrupt Company asking for a loan.
What changed
  • Governor of Bengal becomes Governor-General of Bengal, with a council of 4. First: Warren Hastings.
  • Governors of Bombay and Madras made subordinate to him.
  • Supreme Court at Calcutta, set up in 1774: a chief justice and 3 judges. First chief justice: Sir Elijah Impey.
  • Company servants barred from private trade and from taking gifts or bribes.
  • The Court of Directors must report revenue, civil and military affairs to the British government.
What it led to
The foundation of central administration in India, and the first admission that the Company had political functions, not just trade.

The 1773 Act was rushed and left loose ends. The new Supreme Court began hauling the Governor-General's own officials into court for official acts. In 1781 an amending Act, the Act of Settlement, fenced the court in: the Governor-General and Council were exempted from its jurisdiction for official acts, revenue matters were taken out of its reach, and it was told to apply Hindu law to Hindus and Muslim law to Muslims.

v1784Pitt's India Act Named after Prime Minister William Pitt the Younger

One big change: commerce and politics are split. "Double government."

What broke
1773 had given Parliament oversight but no real control of the Company's political decisions.
What changed
  • The Court of Directors keeps the commercial side.
  • A new Board of Control, of British government ministers, supervises civil, military and revenue matters.
  • The Company's territories are called, for the first time, "British possessions in India".
What it led to
Supreme control of Indian administration now sat with the British government. The Board of Control lasted until 1858.
Double government, in engineering terms

Pitt's Act is separation of concerns: one module (Court of Directors) owns trade, another (Board of Control) owns governance. The trouble with two owners is that each can blame the other. That is exactly what Parliament fixed in 1858 by deleting both.

Two small releases fill the gap. In 1786 Lord Cornwallis agreed to become Governor-General of Bengal only if he could override his council in special cases and also be Commander-in-Chief. The Act of 1786 gave him both. The Charter Act of 1793 extended that overriding power to every future Governor-General and governor, tightened control over Bombay and Madras, and renewed the Company's trade monopoly for another 20 years.

Memory hook: the 20-year licence

The Company's charter was a licence that came up for renewal every 20 years: 1793, 1813, 1833, 1853. Remember one and you have all four. Each renewal was Parliament's chance to take a little more.

v1813Charter Act of 1813

One big change: the trade monopoly ends, except for tea and trade with China.

What broke
British merchants wanted into the Indian market. Free-trade ideas were winning in Britain.
What changed
  • Indian trade opened to all British merchants. Tea and China trade stay with the Company.
  • The Crown's sovereignty over the Company's territories is asserted.
  • Christian missionaries allowed into India.
  • Money provided for spreading Western education.
  • Local governments may tax people and punish non-payment.
What it led to
A Company that is less a merchant every year, and more an administrator.
v1833Charter Act of 1833 The final step of centralisation

One big change: Governor-General of Bengal becomes Governor-General of India. First: Lord William Bentinck.

What broke
Three presidencies making their own laws produced a patchwork. London wanted one government for all of British India.
What changed
  • For the first time, a Government of India with authority over all British territory.
  • Bombay and Madras lose their law-making powers. Only the Governor-General makes laws.
  • Laws made before were "Regulations". Laws from now on are "Acts".
  • The Company's commercial activities end completely. It is purely administrative.
  • Tried to open civil service jobs to open competition, including Indians. The Court of Directors blocked it.
What it led to
The high-water mark of centralisation. From 1861 the pendulum swings back.
v1853Charter Act of 1853 The last Charter Act

One big change: making laws is separated from running the government.

What broke
One council doing both executive work and law-making was slow and unaccountable.
What changed
  • Six legislative members added. A separate Indian (Central) Legislative Council works like a mini-Parliament, using British parliamentary procedure.
  • Local representation begins: 4 of the 6 new members are appointed by the provincial governments of Madras, Bombay, Bengal and Agra.
  • Open competition for the civil services actually begins, open to Indians. The Macaulay Committee is set up in 1854.
  • The Company's rule is extended without a fixed period: Parliament can end it whenever it likes.
What it led to
Five years later, Parliament did end it.
Old coloured map of India in 1857, with British territory in pink and princely states in yellow and green
India in 1857, at the end of Company rule. Pink is territory the British ruled directly; yellow and green are states under Indian rulers (Hindu and Muslim), bound to the British by treaty. Hold on to those yellow and green patches: in 1947 the Independence Act set them free to choose, and integrating them is one reason the Constitution made the Centre strong.Imperial Gazetteer of India, Oxford University Press, 1907 · Public domain · source
Don't confuseYearHow to keep them apart
Governor-General of Bengal1773The first title. Warren Hastings.
Governor-General of India1833The title grows with the territory. William Bentinck.
Viceroy of India1858The Crown's own representative. Lord Canning.
Open competition attempted1833Blocked by the Court of Directors.
Open competition introduced1853Macaulay Committee, 1854.
Supreme Court: which Act1773The Regulating Act provided for it.
Supreme Court: which year1774The year it was actually set up, at Calcutta.
Odisha in the Company years

The 1765 Diwani names "Orissa", but in practice that meant only a small coastal strip around Midnapore. The heart of Odisha, around Cuttack, was held by the Marathas. The Company took it in 1803, during the Second Anglo-Maratha War. Odisha's own rising against Company rule, the Paika rebellion of 1817, came only 14 years later.

Pause and recall: the Company years

Answer each one aloud or on paper first. Then reveal.

  1. Which Act first separated the Company's commercial and political functions, and what was the arrangement called?
    Pitt's India Act, 1784. "Double government": Court of Directors for trade, Board of Control for politics.
  2. Who was the first Governor-General of India, and under which Act?
    Lord William Bentinck, under the Charter Act of 1833.
  3. Name the four Charter Acts and the one big change of the last two.
    1793, 1813, 1833, 1853. 1833: Governor-General of India, Company stops trading. 1853: law-making separated from the executive, open competition for civil services.
  4. In which year was the Supreme Court at Calcutta set up, under which Act, and who was its first chief justice?
    1774, under the Regulating Act of 1773. Sir Elijah Impey.
1858 – 1909 · Sitting 2, about 60 minutes

The Crown takes over

After 1857 Britain rules India directly, and slowly starts letting Indians into the room where laws are made.

Allahabad, 1 November 1858

Lord Canning stands before a crowd to read a proclamation from Queen Victoria. The revolt that began at Meerut in May 1857 has been crushed, but it has frightened London. The East India Company is finished. From today India is governed by, and in the name of, the Queen.

Photographic portrait of Charles Canning, a man in Victorian dress
Lord Canning: the last Governor-General of the Company and the first Viceroy of the Crown, the same man on both sides of 1858. In 1862 he also nominated the first three Indians to the legislative council.John Jabez Edwin Mayall · Public domain · source
v1858Government of India Act, 1858 Also called the Act for the Good Government of India

One big change: the Company is abolished and India passes to the Crown.

What broke
The Revolt of 1857.
What changed
  • The Governor-General is now also Viceroy, the Crown's direct representative. First: Lord Canning.
  • Board of Control and Court of Directors abolished: double government ends.
  • New office of Secretary of State for India, a British Cabinet minister with complete control, answerable to Parliament.
  • A 15-member Council of India advises him. He chairs it.
What it led to
Very little change inside India: the Act mostly rebuilt the machinery in London that supervised India. It was still highly centralised.

The policy of association: three Councils Acts

The revolt taught the British a lesson they stated openly: a government that had no Indians in its councils did not know what Indians were thinking. The answer was to associate Indians with law-making, a little at a time. Three Indian Councils Acts did it, in 1861, 1892 and 1909. Read them as a ladder: each one lets Indians climb one rung higher.

RungHow Indians got inWhat they could do
1861Nominated by the ViceroySit in the expanded council and take part in law-making
1892Recommended by bodies (an indirect, unnamed election)Discuss the budget, ask questions
1909Elected, but Muslims by Muslim voters onlySupplementary questions, budget resolutions; an Indian enters the executive council
v1861Indian Councils Act, 1861

One big change: Indians enter law-making, by nomination.

What broke
1857 showed the cost of governing without Indian voices.
What changed
  • The Viceroy may nominate Indians as non-official members. In 1862 Canning nominated three: the Raja of Benares, the Maharaja of Patiala and Sir Dinkar Rao.
  • Decentralisation begins: Bombay and Madras get law-making powers back, reversing 1833. New councils follow for Bengal (1862), the North-Western Provinces (1886) and Punjab (1897).
  • Legal recognition for Canning's portfolio system of 1859: each council member runs one or more departments.
  • The Viceroy may issue ordinances in an emergency, valid for 6 months.
What it led to
The long road of devolution that ends in provincial autonomy in 1937. The portfolio system is the ancestor of today's ministries.
v1892Indian Councils Act, 1892

One big change: councils may discuss the budget and question the executive.

What broke
The Indian National Congress (founded 1885) was demanding real representation.
What changed
  • More non-official members, but the official majority stays.
  • Councils can discuss the budget and ask questions.
  • A limited, indirect use of election: the Viceroy nominates on the recommendation of provincial councils and the Bengal Chamber of Commerce; governors on the recommendation of district boards, municipalities, universities, zamindars and chambers of commerce. The Act calls it nomination, never election.
What it led to
A taste of representation that made the demand for more much louder.
Simla, 1 October 1906

A delegation of Muslim leaders led by the Aga Khan meets the Viceroy, Lord Minto. If elections are coming, they say, Muslims must be elected by Muslim voters, or a Hindu majority will decide every seat. Minto agrees. Three months later the All-India Muslim League is founded at Dacca.

Photograph of Edwin Montagu in a suit
Edwin Montagu, Secretary of State for India from 1917. His declaration of 20 August 1917 promised "responsible government", the promise behind the 1919 Act in the next sitting.Central News Agency · CC BY 3.0 · source
v1909Indian Councils Act, 1909 Morley-Minto Reforms: Morley the Secretary of State, Minto the Viceroy

One big change: separate electorates for Muslims. Minto is called the "Father of Communal Electorate".

What broke
The Swadeshi agitation after the 1905 partition of Bengal, and the 1906 Simla demand for separate electorates.
What changed
  • Central council enlarged from 16 to 60. Centre keeps an official majority; provinces may have a non-official majority.
  • Members may ask supplementary questions and move resolutions on the budget.
  • Indians join the executive councils for the first time: Satyendra Prasad Sinha becomes the first Indian in the Viceroy's executive council, as Law Member.
  • Separate electorate: Muslim members elected only by Muslim voters. The Act "legalised communalism".
  • Separate representation also for presidency corporations, chambers of commerce, universities and zamindars.
What it led to
Communal representation was extended in 1919 and 1935, and the line it drew ended at Partition.
Traps OCS sets here
  • Indians nominated to the legislative council = 1861. An Indian in the Viceroy's executive council = 1909 (S.P. Sinha). Two different councils, 48 years apart.
  • Separate electorates began in 1909 for Muslims, were extended in 1919 (Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians, Europeans) and in 1932-35 to depressed classes, women and labour.
  • 1892 introduced election in effect, but the Act never used the word.
Pause and recall: the Crown and the councils
  1. Name the three Indian Councils Acts and, for each, how Indians got into the council.
    1861 nominated; 1892 recommended by bodies (indirect election); 1909 elected, with separate electorates for Muslims.
  2. Which Act created the office of Secretary of State for India, and how big was his council?
    Government of India Act 1858. A 15-member Council of India, which he chaired.
  3. What did the 1861 Act do to Bombay and Madras, and why does that matter?
    It gave them back law-making powers taken away in 1833. It started the decentralisation that ended in provincial autonomy (1937).
  4. Who was the first Indian in the Viceroy's executive council, and in what role?
    Satyendra Prasad Sinha, Law Member, under the 1909 Act.
1917 – 1937 · Sitting 3, about 75 minutes

Self-government in instalments

Two big Acts, one failed experiment called dyarchy, and the blueprint that the Constitution would later reuse.

House of Commons, 20 August 1917

The world war has drained Britain and Indian soldiers are dying in France and Mesopotamia. Edwin Montagu tells the House that Britain's goal is now "the gradual development of self-governing institutions with a view to the progressive realisation of responsible government in India". For the first time, self-government is the stated destination. The question is only how slowly.

v1919Government of India Act, 1919 Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms · came into force in 1921

One big change: dyarchy in the provinces.

What broke
Wartime sacrifice and the 1917 promise of responsible government.
What changed
  • Subjects split into a central list and a provincial list, relaxing the Centre's grip.
  • Provincial subjects split again into transferred and reserved: this is dyarchy ("double rule").
  • Bicameralism and direct elections at the Centre: Council of State (upper) and Legislative Assembly (lower). Most members directly elected.
  • 3 of the 6 members of the Viceroy's executive council (other than the Commander-in-Chief) must be Indian.
  • Separate electorates extended to Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians and Europeans.
  • Limited franchise based on property, tax or education.
  • A High Commissioner for India in London.
  • A public service commission: the Central Public Service Commission was set up in 1926.
  • Provincial budgets separated from the central budget.
  • A statutory commission to review the Act after 10 years.
  • A Chamber of Princes (Narendra Mandal), inaugurated in 1921.
What it led to
Dyarchy failed, the review commission came early (Simon, 1927), and the next Act abolished dyarchy in the provinces.

How dyarchy worked, and why it failed

Transferred subjectsReserved subjects
Education, public health, local self-government, agriculturePolice, justice, prisons, land revenue, finance
Run by the Governor with Indian ministers answerable to the legislatureRun by the Governor with his executive council, answerable to no one in India

Look at where finance sits. An Indian minister for education was answerable to the legislature for schools, but the money for schools was in the reserved half, controlled by someone else. Responsibility without control of resources is why dyarchy failed.

From Simon to the Poona Pact

The 1919 Act promised a review after ten years. Britain brought it forward: in November 1927 it appointed a seven-member statutory commission under Sir John Simon. Every member was British. Indians of almost every party boycotted it, and protests met it wherever it went.

Its report of 1930 recommended abolishing dyarchy, extending responsible government in the provinces, a federation of British India and the princely states, and continuing communal electorates. Three Round Table Conferences in London (1930-32) argued over the details, and a White Paper went to a Joint Select Committee of Parliament. Its recommendations, with changes, became the 1935 Act.

Yerawada jail, Poona, September 1932

In August the British Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald announced the Communal Award. It kept separate electorates for Muslims, Sikhs, Indian Christians, Anglo-Indians and Europeans, and extended them to the depressed classes. Gandhi, in jail, began a fast unto death against separating the depressed classes from the Hindu electorate. On 24 September, B.R. Ambedkar, leading the depressed classes, agreed a compromise with Congress leaders: no separate electorate, but reserved seats for the depressed classes inside the joint Hindu electorate. This is the Poona Pact.

Black and white photograph of M.R. Jayakar, Tej Bahadur Sapru and B.R. Ambedkar with others at Yerawada jail
Yerawada jail, 24 September 1932, the day the Poona Pact was signed: M.R. Jayakar, Tej Bahadur Sapru and B.R. Ambedkar. Reserved seats, not separate electorates, is still how India's legislatures include Scheduled Castes today.Unknown author · Public domain · source
v1935Government of India Act, 1935 The longest Act Parliament had passed for India: 321 sections and 10 schedules

One big change: provincial autonomy, and a federal design the Constitution would reuse.

What broke
Dyarchy's failure, the Simon report, the Round Tables, the Communal Award and Poona Pact.
What changed
  • An All-India Federation of provinces and princely states. It never came into being: the princely states did not join.
  • Three lists: Federal 59 items, Provincial 54, Concurrent 36. Residuary powers with the Viceroy.
  • Dyarchy abolished in the provinces, replaced by provincial autonomy: ministers responsible to provincial legislatures. In force 1937, discontinued in 1939.
  • Dyarchy at the Centre provided for, but never came into operation.
  • Bicameral legislatures in 6 of the 11 provinces: Bengal, Bombay, Madras, Bihar, Assam and the United Provinces.
  • Reserved seats for depressed classes (from the Poona Pact); separate representation extended to women and labour.
  • Council of India abolished; the Secretary of State gets a team of advisers.
  • Franchise extended to about 14% of the population.
  • A Reserve Bank of India; a Federal Public Service Commission, Provincial PSCs and Joint PSCs; a Federal Court, set up in 1937.
  • An Auditor-General of India; a Federal Railway Authority; safeguards for minorities.
  • Burma separated from India. Two new provinces created: Orissa and Sind.
What it led to
The skeleton of the 1950 Constitution: the federal scheme, the Governor, the judiciary, public service commissions, emergency powers, administrative detail.
A note on the franchise figure

Laxmikanth (8th edition) gives about 14% of the population. Some other books say about 10%. If an exam option says "about 14%", it follows Laxmikanth. Learn "between a tenth and a seventh" and choose the option that fits.

Odisha: the first province made for a language

Under British rule the Odia-speaking areas were scattered across the Bengal and Madras presidencies and the Central Provinces. In schools and courts Odia was pushed aside.

  • 1903: Madhusudan Das founds the Utkal Sammilani to unite the Odia-speaking tracts.
  • 1912: a new province of Bihar and Orissa is carved out of Bengal. Odisha is still a junior partner.
  • 1 April 1936: Orissa becomes a separate province under the Government of India Act 1935, the first province formed on the basis of language. The day is celebrated as Utkala Dibasa.
  • 1937: under provincial autonomy, Orissa gets its first elected ministry.
Traps OCS sets here
  • Dyarchy was introduced in the provinces by the 1919 Act. The 1935 Act abolished it there and introduced it at the Centre, where it never worked. An option saying "1935 introduced dyarchy" is half true, and a "which Act introduced dyarchy" question wants 1919.
  • Provided by an Act versus actually set up: Public Service Commission 1919 → 1926; Federal Court 1935 → 1937; provincial autonomy 1935 → 1937.
  • 1935 residuary powers went to the Viceroy. In today's Constitution they are with Parliament (Union).
Order it

Drag (or use the arrows) to put these in the order they happened, earliest at the top. Then check.

  1. A company servant is barred from accepting gifts from "natives" (1773)
  2. A Board of Control is created in London (1784)
  3. Laws start to be called "Acts" instead of "Regulations" (1833)
  4. Civil services opened to open competition (1853)
  5. A 15-member Council of India is set up (1858)
  6. The portfolio system gets legal recognition (1861)
  7. Councils may first discuss the budget (1892)
  8. Central legislative council grows from 16 to 60 (1909)
  9. A High Commissioner for India appointed in London (1919)
  10. Burma separated from India (1935)
Pause and recall: 1919 and 1935
  1. Under dyarchy, who ran the transferred subjects, and to whom were they answerable?
    The Governor with Indian ministers answerable to the provincial legislative council.
  2. Give the three lists of the 1935 Act with their item counts, and where residuary powers went.
    Federal 59, Provincial 54, Concurrent 36. Residuary with the Viceroy (Governor-General).
  3. Name three institutions the 1935 Act provided for that still exist today in some form.
    Any three of: Reserve Bank of India, Federal Court (ancestor of the Supreme Court), Federal/Provincial Public Service Commissions, Auditor-General.
  4. What did the Poona Pact replace, and with what?
    It replaced separate electorates for the depressed classes (from the Communal Award) with reserved seats inside the joint Hindu electorate.
  5. When did Orissa become a separate province, and under which Act?
    1 April 1936, under the Government of India Act 1935.
1939 – 1947 · Sitting 4, about 60 minutes

Eight years, five offers, one partition

The Second World War forces Britain to bargain. Each offer goes a little further, and each is refused, until the country is divided.

3 September 1939

The Viceroy, Lord Linlithgow, announces that India is at war with Germany. He has not asked a single Indian leader. Within weeks the Congress ministries in the provinces, elected only two years earlier under the 1935 Act, resign in protest. Provincial autonomy is over almost as soon as it began.

The idea of a Constituent Assembly

Through all of this ran one Indian demand: Indians, not the British Parliament, must write India's constitution. The idea was first put forward in 1934 by M.N. Roy, a pioneer of Indian communism. The Congress officially demanded a Constituent Assembly in 1935, and in 1938 Nehru declared that free India's constitution must be framed, without outside interference, by an assembly elected on adult franchise.

Aug 1940The August Offer 8 August 1940, by the Viceroy Lord Linlithgow

One big change: Britain accepts, for the first time, that Indians will frame their own constitution.

What broke
Britain needed Indian support for the war. Congress ministries had resigned.
What it offered
  • Dominion Status named as the objective for India.
  • After the war, a body representative of Indians would frame the constitution.
  • The Viceroy's executive council expanded to include more Indians.
  • A War Advisory Council.
  • No constitution would be imposed against the will of large and powerful sections of the people: in effect, a veto for the minorities.
What it led to
Congress rejected it and began individual satyagraha. The Muslim League welcomed the minorities' veto.
The August Offer, word by word
  • The constitution-making body was to be representative. An option saying "nominated" is wrong.
  • Dominion Status was the stated objective. An option saying it was "not the objective" is wrong.
  • The body was to be formed after the war, not immediately.

March 1940: the Lahore Resolution

Five months before the August Offer, on 23 March 1940, the All-India Muslim League meeting at Lahore passed a resolution demanding that the Muslim-majority areas in the north-west and east of India be grouped into "independent states". The resolution was moved by A.K. Fazlul Huq. It is remembered as the Pakistan Resolution: from here on, the League's demand was not safeguards inside one India but a separate homeland.

Black and white photograph of Stafford Cripps with Mahatma Gandhi on the steps of Birla House, Delhi
Sir Stafford Cripps with Gandhi, Delhi, April 1942. Cripps brought a draft offer from the British Cabinet. It was rejected by every major party, for opposite reasons.No 9 Army Film & Photographic Unit · Public domain · source
1942The Cripps Mission March to April 1942, Sir Stafford Cripps, a member of the British Cabinet

One big change: a constitution-making body after the war, with any province free to stay out.

What broke
Japan had taken Singapore and Rangoon and was at India's eastern door.
What it offered
  • Dominion Status after the war.
  • A constitution-making body after the war: members elected by the provincial legislatures, plus nominees of the princely states.
  • Any province could refuse to join the new Union and frame its own constitution.
  • Defence to stay under British control during the war.
What it led to
Rejected. Congress objected to the opt-out (it opened the door to partition) and to keeping defence British; the League wanted Pakistan accepted outright. Quit India followed in August 1942.

1945 to 1946: Simla, and a Cabinet Mission

The Wavell Plan and the Simla Conference of June-July 1945 tried to form an executive council of Indian leaders. It broke down when the League insisted that it alone could nominate every Muslim member.

The war ended, Britain had a new Labour government, and in March 1946 it sent three Cabinet ministers to settle the question: Lord Pethick-Lawrence (Secretary of State for India), Sir Stafford Cripps and A.V. Alexander. This was the Cabinet Mission.

Black and white photograph of the British Cabinet Mission members in Delhi, 1946
The British Cabinet Mission in India, 1946. Its plan of 16 May 1946 rejected a separate Pakistan, but grouped the provinces so loosely that the League could accept it. It also designed the Constituent Assembly.No 9 Army Film & Photographic Unit · Public domain · source
1946The Cabinet Mission Plan Announced 16 May 1946

One big change: it designed the Constituent Assembly that wrote the Constitution.

What broke
The war was over; Britain could no longer afford to hold India.
What it proposed
  • A Union of India covering defence, foreign affairs and communications; everything else with provinces and states.
  • Provinces grouped into three sections (A, B, C), the League's areas in B and C.
  • Rejected a separate Pakistan.
  • A Constituent Assembly of 389, elected indirectly by the provincial assemblies (details in Sitting 5).
  • An Interim Government of Indian leaders.
What it led to
Assembly elections in July-August 1946, and an Interim Government under Nehru from 2 September 1946. The League, rejecting the plan in July, called Direct Action Day on 16 August 1946; Calcutta saw days of killing.
v1947Indian Independence Act, 1947 Bill introduced 4 July · royal assent 18 July · in force 15 August 1947

One big change: India becomes an independent, sovereign state.

What broke
On 20 February 1947 Prime Minister Attlee announced that British rule would end by June 1948. Violence spread. On 3 June 1947 the Viceroy, Lord Mountbatten, announced a plan to partition the country, accepted by Congress and the League. The date was brought forward to 15 August 1947.
What changed
  • British rule ends; India is independent from 15 August 1947.
  • Partition into two dominions, India and Pakistan, each free to leave the Commonwealth.
  • Office of Viceroy abolished. Each dominion gets a Governor-General, appointed by the King on the advice of the dominion's cabinet.
  • Each Constituent Assembly may frame any constitution and repeal any British law, including this Act. It is also the dominion's legislature until then.
  • Secretary of State for India abolished.
  • British paramountcy over the princely states lapses: they may join India or Pakistan, or stay independent.
  • The King drops the title Emperor of India.
  • Both dominions governed under the 1935 Act, as adapted, until their own constitutions arrive. Governor-General and governors become nominal heads acting on ministers' advice.
What it led to
Lord Mountbatten became the first Governor-General of free India and swore in Nehru as Prime Minister. C. Rajagopalachari later became the first and last Indian Governor-General.
Pause and recall: the road to 1947
  1. Who first put forward the idea of a Constituent Assembly for India, and when?
    M.N. Roy, in 1934.
  2. Give three terms of the August Offer.
    Any three: Dominion Status as the objective; a representative body of Indians to frame the constitution after the war; more Indians in the Viceroy's executive council; a War Advisory Council; minorities' consent for any constitution.
  3. Why did Congress reject the Cripps proposals?
    Provinces could opt out of the Union (a road to partition), and defence was to stay British during the war.
  4. What did the Cabinet Mission Plan say about Pakistan, and what did it create that matters for this module?
    It rejected a separate Pakistan, and it designed the Constituent Assembly (389 seats).
  5. Give the four dates of 1947: Attlee's announcement, the Mountbatten Plan, royal assent, independence.
    20 February; 3 June; 18 July; 15 August.
1946 · Sitting 5, about 75 minutes

The Assembly: who sat in it

389 seats were planned, 296 were elected, 299 finished the job. Build it yourself below.

How the seats were designed

The Cabinet Mission Plan fixed the rules, and the Assembly was constituted in November 1946:

So the Assembly was partly elected and partly nominated, and the elected part was elected indirectly, by provincial legislators who had themselves been elected on a limited franchise. It was not chosen by adult franchise.

Memory hook: the four numbers

389 → 296 → 299 → 284. Planned, elected, after partition, signed. In the 1946 vote: 208 / 73 / 15 (Congress, League, others). And the 93 princely seats were not filled in 1946.

Who was in the room

Not directly elected, but wide. The Assembly included Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs, Parsis, Anglo-Indians, Indian Christians, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, and 15 women. Almost every important figure of the time sat in it, with one notable exception: Mahatma Gandhi.

Photograph of Malati Choudhury
Malati Choudhury, member for Orissa (General) and one of the 15 women in the Constituent Assembly. Orissa had 9 members as on 31 December 1947.Amlanmohanty at English Wikipedia · CC BY-SA 3.0 · source
Odisha in the Assembly

Orissa, a province only since 1936, sent 9 members (as on 31 December 1947). Among them was Malati Choudhury, a Gandhian who had worked among the poor and tribal people of Odisha, one of the 15 women members.

Pause and recall: the Assembly's make-up
  1. Break 389 into its parts.
    296 British India (292 governors' provinces + 4 chief commissioners' provinces) + 93 princely states.
  2. How were the members from the provinces chosen?
    Indirectly: by the members of each community in the provincial legislative assembly, by proportional representation through single transferable vote.
  3. What were the results of the July-August 1946 elections, and what happened to the princely seats?
    Congress 208, Muslim League 73, small groups and independents 15. The 93 princely seats were not filled.
  4. What was the Assembly's strength after partition, and how was it split?
    299: 229 from the provinces and 70 from the princely states.

The Assembly at work

Constitution Hall, New Delhi, 11 a.m., 9 December 1946

The Muslim League has boycotted the session and is demanding Pakistan. About 207 members take their seats (Laxmikanth's figure; some books say 211). Following French practice, the oldest member, Dr Sachchidananda Sinha, is elected temporary Chairman. Two days later, on 11 December, Dr Rajendra Prasad is elected President of the Assembly.

The specification: the Objectives Resolution

On 13 December 1946 Nehru moved the Objectives Resolution. In engineering terms, it was the requirements document for the whole project. It said India would be an independent sovereign republic; a union of the provinces and states with autonomous units holding residuary powers; all power deriving from the people; justice (social, economic, political), equality of status and opportunity, and freedoms of thought, expression, belief, faith, worship, vocation, association and action; safeguards for minorities, backward and tribal areas and depressed classes; and that India would contribute to world peace.

It was adopted unanimously on 22 January 1947. A modified version of it became the Preamble.

OfficeWhoWhen
Temporary ChairmanDr Sachchidananda Sinha (oldest member)9 December 1946
PresidentDr Rajendra Prasad11 December 1946
Vice-PresidentH.C. Mukherjee25 January 1947
Second Vice-PresidentV.T. Krishnamachari16 July 1947
Constitutional (legal) adviserSir B.N. Rau
SecretaryH.V.R. Iyengar
Chief draftsmanS.N. Mukherjee

What independence did to the Assembly

The princely states' representatives drifted in during 1947: six states were represented by 28 April 1947, and most others joined after the Mountbatten Plan. The Indian Independence Act then changed the Assembly in three ways:

  1. It became fully sovereign: free to frame any constitution and to repeal or alter any British law about India.
  2. It also became the legislature of the dominion, the first Parliament of free India. As constitution-maker it was chaired by Rajendra Prasad; as legislature, by G.V. Mavalankar. The two roles met on different days, until 26 November 1949.
  3. Members from areas that went to Pakistan withdrew, bringing the strength down to 299.

Committees: how the work was divided

The Assembly worked through committees: eight major ones and many minor ones. You do not need all of them. You need the major ones, and a pattern that rebuilds them:

Memory hook: who chaired what
  • Nehru chaired the committees about the Union and the States: Union Powers, Union Constitution, and the States Committee (negotiating with princely states).
  • Patel chaired the committees about the provinces and the people's rights: Provincial Constitution, and the Advisory Committee on Fundamental Rights, Minorities and Tribal and Excluded Areas.
  • Rajendra Prasad, as President, chaired the housekeeping: Rules of Procedure, Steering, Finance and Staff, and the ad hoc committee on the National Flag.
  • Ambedkar chaired Drafting.

The Advisory Committee under Patel had sub-committees: Fundamental Rights (J.B. Kripalani), Minorities (H.C. Mukherjee), North-East Frontier Tribal Areas and Assam Excluded and Partially Excluded Areas (Gopinath Bardoloi), Excluded and Partially Excluded Areas other than Assam (A.V. Thakkar), and North-West Frontier Tribal Areas. Among the minor committees: Credentials (Alladi Krishnaswamy Ayyar), House (B. Pattabhi Sitaramayya), Order of Business (K.M. Munshi), Functions of the Constituent Assembly (G.V. Mavalankar), Press Gallery (Usha Nath Sen). Three were chaired by non-members: the ad hoc committee on the Supreme Court and on Citizenship (S. Varadachari), the Expert Committee on Financial Provisions (Nalini Ranjan Sarkar), and the Linguistic Provinces Commission (S.K. Dar).

Match it: who chaired the committee?
Union Powers CommitteeNehru: everything about the Union and the States.
Provincial Constitution CommitteePatel: the provinces.
Drafting CommitteeAmbedkar chaired Drafting.
Steering CommitteePrasad, as President, chaired the housekeeping committees.
States Committee (negotiating with princely states)Nehru: the States.
Advisory Committee on Fundamental Rights, Minorities and Tribal and Excluded AreasPatel: the people's rights, through the Advisory Committee.
Fundamental Rights Sub-CommitteeA sub-committee of Patel's Advisory Committee, chaired by Kripalani.
Rules of Procedure CommitteeHousekeeping: Prasad.

The Drafting Committee

Set up on 29 August 1947, with seven members:

  1. Dr B.R. Ambedkar (Chairman)
  2. N. Gopalaswamy Ayyangar
  3. Alladi Krishnaswamy Ayyar
  4. Dr K.M. Munshi
  5. Syed Mohammad Saadullah
  6. N. Madhava Rau, who replaced B.L. Mitter (resigned, ill-health)
  7. T.T. Krishnamachari, who replaced D.P. Khaitan (died, 1948)
The release process, 1947 to 1949
  • Draft v1 published February 1948. The public got eight months of review.
  • Draft v2, revised from public comments, published October 1948.
  • First reading: Ambedkar introduced the final draft on 4 November 1948; general discussion for five days.
  • Second reading, clause by clause: 15 November 1948 to 17 October 1949. 7,653 amendments proposed, 2,473 actually discussed. These were the change requests.
  • Third reading from 14 November 1949. On 26 November 1949 the motion was declared passed and members signed.
Black and white photograph of B.R. Ambedkar handing the final draft of the Constitution to Rajendra Prasad
25 November 1949: B.R. Ambedkar, chairman of the Drafting Committee, presents the final draft to Rajendra Prasad, President of the Assembly. Ambedkar piloted the draft through the Assembly and is called the Father of the Constitution and its chief architect.Unknown author · Public domain · source

Adopted, then in force: two different dates

26 November 1949: adopted26 January 1950: commenced
The date written in the Preamble: "do hereby adopt, enact and give to ourselves this Constitution". Since 2015, Constitution Day (Samvidhan Divas).The "date of its commencement". Celebrated as Republic Day.
Some provisions came into force at once: citizenship, elections, the provisional Parliament, temporary and transitional provisions, and the short title (Articles 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 60, 324, 366, 367, 379, 380, 388, 391, 392 and 393).Everything else came into force. Chosen because on 26 January 1930 India celebrated Purna Swaraj Day, following the Lahore session of Congress in December 1929.
As adopted: a Preamble, 395 Articles and 8 Schedules. The Preamble was enacted last, after the rest.On commencement, the Indian Independence Act 1947 and the Government of India Act 1935 were repealed. The Abolition of Privy Council Jurisdiction Act 1949 continued.

What else the Assembly did

  • Adopted the national flag: 22 July 1947.
  • Ratified India's membership of the Commonwealth: May 1949.
  • Adopted the national anthem and national song: 24 January 1950.
  • Elected Rajendra Prasad the first President of India: 24 January 1950.

In all: 11 sessions over 2 years, 11 months and 18 days; the constitutions of about 60 countries consulted; the Draft considered for 114 days; total cost about ₹64 lakh. After its final session on 24 January 1950 it continued as the provisional Parliament until the first elected Parliament after the 1951-52 general election.

The illuminated original Preamble page of the Constitution of India, handwritten in calligraphy with a decorated border
The Preamble as it appears in the original Constitution. The English text was handwritten in flowing italic by Prem Behari Narain Raizada; artists from Shantiniketan led by Nandalal Bose decorated the pages, and Beohar Rammanohar Sinha illuminated the Preamble. The Hindi version was calligraphed by Vasant Krishan Vaidya.Constituent Assembly of India · EdictGov-India · source
Small facts that become questions
  • The elephant was the symbol (seal) of the Constituent Assembly.
  • The Congress Experts Committee (July 1946, chaired by Nehru) prepared material for the Assembly, including a draft close to the Objectives Resolution.
Pause and recall: the Assembly at work
  1. Who was the temporary Chairman, why him, and when did Rajendra Prasad take over?
    Dr Sachchidananda Sinha, the oldest member, following French practice. Prasad was elected President on 11 December 1946.
  2. When was the Objectives Resolution moved and when adopted? What did it become?
    Moved 13 December 1946, adopted 22 January 1947. Its modified version is the Preamble.
  3. Who chaired the Assembly when it sat as the legislature?
    G.V. Mavalankar.
  4. When was the Drafting Committee set up and how many members did it have?
    29 August 1947, seven members.
  5. Name four kinds of provisions that came into force on 26 November 1949.
    Any four: citizenship, elections, provisional Parliament, temporary and transitional provisions, short title.
  6. What did the Constitution contain as adopted?
    A Preamble, 395 Articles (in 22 Parts) and 8 Schedules.

Was the Assembly legitimate? Thinking like a mains answer

Critics attacked the Assembly from the day it met. Mains questions love this ground because there is no single right answer: you are paid for weighing the criticism against the reply. Read each row as an argument and a counter-argument.

CriticismWhat critics saidThe reply
Not representativeMembers were not directly elected on universal adult franchise.It drew members from every community, region and shade of opinion, and its debates were public and recorded. Direct elections across a divided country in 1946 were not practical.
Not sovereignIt was created by a British plan and met with British permission.The Indian Independence Act made it fully sovereign. Its authority came from the people it represented, as the Preamble says: "We, the people".
Too slowNearly three years, while the US framers took about four months.India's task was far larger and its constitution far longer, written amid partition and the merger of princely states. One member mocked the "Drifting Committee"; the record of 7,653 proposed amendments shows why it took time.
One-party bodyDominated by Congress. Granville Austin: "The Assembly was the Congress and the Congress was India."Congress itself was a broad coalition of views, and the Assembly brought in non-Congress talent, Ambedkar above all.
Lawyers' bodyDominated by lawyers and politicians; hence the bulk and legal language.Precision in a founding document is a virtue, and the legal detail is what lets courts enforce it.
Hindu-dominatedLord Simon called it "a body of Hindus"; Churchill said it represented only one major community.It wrote some of the strongest minority safeguards of any constitution of its time.

What 1950 inherited, and why the Centre is strong

The Constitution did not start from nothing. Its structure came largely from the 1935 Act: the federal scheme with lists of subjects, the office of Governor, the judiciary, public service commissions, emergency powers and much administrative detail. Its philosophy (the Preamble, Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles) came from the freedom struggle and from other constitutions. Module 2 maps every borrowed piece to its source.

The Cabinet Mission had proposed a weak Union holding only defence, foreign affairs and communications. The Constitution that came out instead has a strong Centre. Why the change? Four pressures, all visible in this module:

  1. Partition and its violence. Once Pakistan was accepted in June 1947, the main reason for a weak Centre, keeping the League inside one India, disappeared, and the overriding need became unity and security.
  2. Integrating more than 500 princely states, freed by the lapse of paramountcy in August 1947, needed a Union with authority. In Odisha the princely states merged with the province on 1 January 1948, and Mayurbhanj on 1 January 1949.
  3. Planned economic development and the fight against poverty were expected to need central coordination.
  4. Continuity with the 1935 Act, which already gave the Centre wide powers and the Viceroy the residuary powers.

You will meet the provisions that make the Centre strong (residuary powers, Article 3, emergency powers, Governors, all-India services) in Modules 3, 7 and 8. This module tells you why the Assembly chose them.

One sentence to carry forward

The Constitution kept the colonial machinery of 1935 and replaced its source of authority: power now comes from "We, the people of India", not from the British Parliament.

One-page revision sheet

Cover the right-hand column and recall it. Do this on day 1, day 3, day 7 and day 21 after finishing the module.

ReleaseRemember it as
1773 Regulating ActGG of Bengal (Hastings), Bombay and Madras subordinate, Supreme Court Calcutta 1774 (Impey)
1781 Act of SettlementFixes 1773: GG and council outside the Supreme Court for official acts
1784 Pitt's India ActDouble government: Court of Directors (trade) + Board of Control (politics); "British possessions in India"
1786 / 1793GG may override council, also Commander-in-Chief (Cornwallis) / made permanent; monopoly renewed 20 years
1813 CharterMonopoly ends except tea and China; missionaries; education money
1833 CharterGG of India (Bentinck); only GG makes law; "Acts"; Company stops trading; open competition attempted
1853 CharterLegislature separated from executive (mini-Parliament); local representation; open competition (Macaulay Committee 1854)
1858 GoI ActCrown rule; Viceroy (Canning); Secretary of State + 15-member Council of India; double government ends
1861 Councils ActIndians nominated (1862: Benares, Patiala, Dinkar Rao); Bombay and Madras get law-making back; portfolio system; ordinances 6 months
1892 Councils ActBudget discussion, questions; indirect election, never called election
1909 Morley-MintoSeparate electorate for Muslims (Minto); council 16 → 60; S.P. Sinha, Law Member
1919 Montagu-ChelmsfordDyarchy in provinces; bicameral Centre, direct elections; separate provincial budgets; CPSC (1926); in force 1921
1927-1932Simon Commission (all British) → Round Tables → Communal Award (Aug 1932) → Poona Pact (Sept 1932)
1935 GoI ActProvincial autonomy (1937); lists 59 / 54 / 36; residuary with Viceroy; Federal Court (1937); RBI; PSCs; 6 bicameral provinces; Orissa and Sind created; Burma separated
1940-1946Lahore Resolution (Mar 1940); August Offer (8 Aug 1940); Cripps (1942); Wavell / Simla (1945); Cabinet Mission (16 May 1946); Interim Government (2 Sept 1946)
1947 Independence Act15 Aug 1947; two dominions; Viceroy and Secretary of State abolished; paramountcy lapses; Assembly sovereign + legislature
The Assembly389 → 296 (208 / 73 / 15) → 299 → 284 signed; 9 Dec 1946 first sitting; Objectives Resolution 13 Dec 1946 / 22 Jan 1947; Drafting Committee 29 Aug 1947, 7 members
1949-1950Adopted 26 Nov 1949 (Preamble, 395 Articles, 8 Schedules); in force 26 Jan 1950 (Purna Swaraj Day, 1930)
OdishaCompany takes Cuttack 1803; Utkal Sammilani 1903; separate province 1 April 1936; 9 Assembly members; Malati Choudhury; princely states merged 1 Jan 1948

Flashcards

Cards come back on a schedule: the ones you forget return tomorrow, the ones you remember come back after 1, 3, 7 and then 21 days. Five minutes a day is enough.

Module test

25 practice questions written in the OCS style (they are not past OCS questions: those are kept for the final exam). Marked as OCS marks: +2 right, −0.66 wrong, 0 skipped. Take it in one sitting, without looking back at the module. Your score is saved.

Loading the test…

Mains thinking studio

Two practice questions in the shape OCS sets them. For each: plan in the boxes, then compare your plan with the model plan, then write the full answer by hand within the word limit, photograph it, and upload it. Ask Claude to grade it in your next session.

Practice question 1 · Group A style · 250 words · 15 marks

"The Government of India Act, 1935 gave the Indian Constitution its skeleton, but not its soul." Examine.

1. Decode the question

Examine asks you to look at the claim from more than one side and reach a judgement. You must show the skeleton part (what was borrowed), the soul part (what was new), and say how far the statement holds.

2. Sweep the dimensions

3. Plan your answer

Introduction. The 1935 Act, with 321 sections and 10 schedules, was the most detailed constitutional law Britain made for India; the Constitution of 1950 reused much of its machinery while changing its source of authority.

Skeleton (borrowed from 1935): federal scheme with three lists (59 / 54 / 36 then); office of Governor; Federal Court → Supreme Court; Federal and Provincial PSCs → UPSC and State PSCs; emergency powers; Auditor-General → CAG; administrative detail; bicameral legislatures in some provinces.

Soul (new in 1950): sovereignty of the people ("We, the people"), not of the British Parliament; universal adult franchise instead of about 14%; justiciable Fundamental Rights; Directive Principles for a welfare state; an elected head of state (republic); judicial review; abolition of separate electorates, replaced by reserved seats.

Qualify it: the skeleton itself was altered: residuary powers moved from the Governor-General to Parliament, dyarchy disappeared, the Governor became a constitutional head. And the "soul" had roots in the Objectives Resolution and the freedom struggle, not in a single Act.

Conclusion. The statement largely holds: the structure is colonial in origin, the values are Indian. Add one line that the Constitution "Indianised" the borrowed structure by making it answer to the people.

4. Write it by hand, then upload

Practice question 2 · Group B style · 300 words · 20 marks

The Constituent Assembly has been criticised as neither representative nor sovereign. Examine these criticisms and assess how far the Assembly overcame them in making the Constitution.

1. Decode the question

Two tasks. Examine the two criticisms with facts, then assess (give a reasoned verdict) how far the Assembly answered them. A good answer gives the facts behind each criticism before defending the Assembly.

2. Sweep the dimensions

3. Plan your answer

Introduction. Formed in November 1946 under the Cabinet Mission Plan, the Assembly framed the Constitution adopted on 26 November 1949. Two charges were made against its legitimacy.

Not representative, the facts: indirect election by provincial assemblies elected on a limited franchise; communal division of seats; princely nominees; Muslim League boycott at the first sitting.

The answer: membership drawn from all communities, SCs and STs, 15 women, every major region (Orissa's 9 members, for example); open, recorded debates; draft published in February 1948 for eight months of public comment; 7,653 amendments proposed.

Not sovereign, the facts: created by a British plan; first met while British rule continued.

The answer: the Indian Independence Act made it fully sovereign, free to repeal any British law; it repealed the 1935 and 1947 Acts on commencement; the Preamble grounds authority in "We, the people".

Assessment. The procedural criticisms were real in 1946 but were overcome in substance: universal adult franchise in the Constitution itself, the first general election of 1951-52, and the Constitution's durability show that its legitimacy came from its content and its acceptance, not only from how its makers were chosen.

4. Write it by hand, then upload

Three days later: recall test

Ten questions, taken at least three days after the module test, without re-reading anything first. This is the honest measure of what stayed.

Checking whether it is unlocked…